If you’re in talent acquisition, you’ve probably experienced this: a role opens, resumes flood in and, within minutes, your ATS is overflowing with candidates — most of them unqualified or just simply not the right fit for the job.

Now, multiply that across dozens of roles. 

In other words, your team is spending hours if not days and weeks on talent that won’t make the mark and slowing the hiring process all the while. Meanwhile, your top talent is out there getting poached by teams with faster, more efficient solutions.

That’s why more teams are turning to AI resume screening software to get ahead. These 5 tools are some of the best on the market, and we’ll dive into why — and who they’re best suited for.

What AI Resume Screening Is…

AI resume screening is exactly what it sounds like. It’s software that uses artificial intelligence to automatically evaluate resumes and identify the most qualified candidates for a role. 

Before, it used a simple keyword-matching algorithm — but it has come a long, long way.

Today’s top AI screening tools analyze everything from skills and experience to career trajectory and behavioral signals. They can read between the lines and understand not just what’s listed on a resume, but how it aligns with the actual needs of the job. 

Some tools even factor in how a candidate has engaged with your brand or roles in the past, giving you a fuller picture before you’ve even scheduled a call.

AI resume screening tools free up time spent buried in resumes, and allow more time for talent specialists to connect with candidates who actually fit the buck.

…And Why It Matters

Done well, AI screening doesn’t just save time. It helps:

• Prioritize qualified applicants faster
• Reduce bias in early-stage filtering
• Improve candidate experience with faster follow-up
• Give recruiters more time for meaningful conversations

AI resume screening is not about removing humans from the process. Instead, it’s about removing the noise. If you’re curious about the role AI plays in recruiting, it’s best to start here before you explore software. 

Here are five tools that are leading the way and how they stack up:

The 5 Best AI Resume Screening Tools on the Market

1. Puck

Best for: Mid-market orgs looking for smart screening with a branded, human experience

Puck brings AI screening into the broader hiring experience so you’re not just identifying great candidates — rather, you’re engaging them in a way that reflects your company’s values and voice.

Our resume screening engine evaluates fit based on skills, engagement data, and behavioral cues then brings them to the surface. 

But, unlike standalone tools, Puck doesn’t just score candidates; we move them into personalized journeys, branded pages, and conversion-optimized touchpoints. It’s AI resume screening with storytelling built in.

Highlights:

• Smart-fit scoring based on more than just resumes
• Customizable recruiter review tools
• Integrated employer branding and apply experience

💡 SKIMS worked with Puck to improve their candidate experience. The result? Better candidates put in seats faster. See how they did it.

2. Paradox.ai

Best for: High-volume, hourly, and frontline hiring

Paradox’s AI assistant, Olivia, screens candidates via chat by asking role-specific questions, confirming eligibility, and scheduling interviews on the spot.

Highlights:

• Chat-based qualification and scheduling
• Available via SMS, web, and mobile
• Designed for speed hiring at scale

3. HireVue

Best for: Structured AI resume screening combined with assessment tools

HireVue doesn’t just parse resumes. They layer on assessments and video interviews for a deeper early-stage evaluation. That means recruiters can consider not just what someone says they’ve done, but how they communicate, solve problems, or think critically.

Highlights:

• Resume parsing + video scoring
• Structured assessment library
• Hiring gamification

4. Fetcher

Best for: Small teams who want automation and outreach in one

Fetcher sources candidates, screens their resumes against your job criteria, and then kicks off personalized outbound outreach.

Highlights:

• Role matching and email sequencing
• Built-in analytics for engagement
• Interview scheduling integrations

5. Eightfold AI

Best for: Enterprise orgs focused on skills-first hiring

Eightfold uses a proprietary “skills graph” to match candidates to jobs based on capability, not just job titles.

Highlights:

• Skills-based matching engine
• DEI-aware filtering
• Talent intelligence at scale

Why Puck Leads in AI Resume Screening for Modern Talent Teams

Most AI screening tools stop at shortlisting candidates. Puck goes further, bridging the gap between fit and follow-through.

We combine intelligent AI resume screening with branded content and personalized candidate journeys. Together, Puck helps your team move faster without losing the human element. It’s powerful tech built to amplify what your team does best: find quality candidates that want to work with you for the long haul.

See it for action yourself by booking a personalized demo → click here!

‍