Most companies are great at chasing candidates once a role opens. Fewer are great at staying in touch when nothing is open yet.

That’s where candidate nurture sequences come in.

They are how smart recruiting teams build trust, stay top of mind, and fill roles faster without scrambling.

The best part? 

You do not need a 20-person team or fancy tech to start.

You just need the right system and the right words.

In this guide, we’ll break down what a strong candidate nurture sequence looks like, why it matters more than ever in 2025, and give you real templates you can steal and start using today.

What Is a Candidate Nurture Sequence (and Why You Need One)

‍

A candidate nurture sequence is a way to start a real relationship with top talent before you even have a seat to fill.

A strong nurture sequence does a few key things:

• It builds trust while you're not hiring.
• It keeps great candidates warm without feeling like you're hovering.
• It shortens your time-to-fill when roles finally open because candidates already know (and like) you.

A well-run nurture sequence outperforms cold outreach every single time. Cold emails are asking for trust in the first 30 seconds. 

Nurture sequences earn it over time.

If you want to stop “spraying and praying” every time a req drops, building real nurture systems is how you do it.

And when your database is full of qualified, refreshed profiles — like the ones Puck automatically surfaces and updates for you…staying top of mind gets even easier.

Read More: How to be a Good Recruiter: 10 Experts Share Advice

How Smart Candidate Nurturing Strategies Turn Interest into Action

Most people treat nurture like a marketing calendar. Send a few emails. Post a job. Hope somebody’s interested.

But building real relationships takes more than timing.

Here’s what separates a forgettable sequence from one that moves the needle:

1. Personalization Beyond First Names

Most "personalized" emails just stick a first name at the top. Candidates can smell that from a mile away.

Real personalization looks like:

• Mentioning a certification they just earned.
• Calling out a side project they posted about.
• Congratulating them on a promotion.

Show that you know something about them, and you actually care. That’s how you move a passive candidate from "meh" to "hmm, maybe."

2. Timing That Feels Natural (Not Annoying)

One email every two days? That feels desperate.

One email every six months? That feels like you forgot they exist.

The best teams create a light, steady presence.

• Maybe a soft touchpoint every few weeks if they’re actively exploring.
• Maybe a quarterly check-in if they’re more passive.

Puck, for example, helps talent leaders track candidate engagement behind the scenes– meaning you know who is warming up and when to nudge them.

3. The Content Gives Them Something Real

There’s only so much interest you can spark by listing job openings.

When you share a story about a new hire who took a chance and thrived, it sticks. When a hiring manager talks about a real challenge the team is solving, it sticks.

Behind-the-scenes glimpses beat corporate buzzwords every time.

Candidates want to imagine themselves doing the work, not just filling a job description.

4. There’s an Open Door, Not a Hard Pitch

Nobody likes feeling pushed.

Strong sequences end with an easy way to lean in.

• Reply for a quick intro call.
• Sign up for a behind-the-scenes webinar.

Keep it casual, simple, and pressure-free.

When candidates are ready, they’ll step through.

5. The Tone Sounds Like a Real Person, Not a Robot

Most candidates aren’t reading your emails at a desk. They’re on the subway, standing in line at a coffee shop, scrolling before bed.

A warm, human note cuts through.

A stiff corporate memo doesn’t.

You have to make an impression that says, "This is a team you'd want to work with."

Read More: Everything You Need to Know About Text Recruiting

4 Candidate Nurturing Templates Every Talent Team Should Steal

Every candidate in your world is at a different stage. Some are curious. Some are committed. Some are not even looking yet.

One-size-fits-all nurturing doesn’t work anymore.

If you want a real system that moves talent closer over time, you need sequences built for where people are.

Here’s what every serious talent team should have:

1. New Prospect Sequence

For candidates who have just entered your pipeline

The first touch matters. 

When someone shows up in your system, whether from sourcing, referral, or inbound, they don’t know you yet. 

Your job isn't to throw a job req at them. It’s to make an introduction they’ll remember.

With Puck’s Candidate Matching, you can immediately see which prospects actually align with your roles. No manual digging required.

Here’s a Quick Template:

• Start with a simple welcome note.
• Share a quick story about the company, something real, not marketing fluff.
• Drop a light glimpse into your culture — maybe a team tradition or a project people are excited about.
• End with a soft invite to stay connected. No pressure to apply, just an open door.

Email 1: The Welcome Note

Subject Line: Welcome — glad you found us.

Body:

Hey [First Name],

Just wanted to say thanks for checking us out. Always excited when new folks pop into our orbit.

If you're ever curious about life here at [Company Name], we’d love to give you a real peek behind the scenes.

More soon, but in the meantime, glad to have you on our radar.

Cheers,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Email 2: Share a Quick Story About the Company

(Send a few days later.)

Subject Line: A quick story we love

Body:

Hi [First Name],

When people ask what it’s like to work at [Company Name], this story usually comes up.

Last year, [insert short, real story — e.g., "a few engineers stayed late after a launch to write thank-you notes to a partner team that helped out... completely unprompted."]

It’s small moments like that that remind us why we’re here.

More to share soon — but figured you’d appreciate a glimpse into the real stuff.

Talk soon,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Email 3: Culture Peek

(One week after the story email.)

Subject Line: Inside [Company Name]: What we’re proud of lately

Body:

Hey [First Name],

One thing that’s been buzzing around [Company Name] lately — [insert something real like "our quarterly hackathon," "our DEI coffee chats," or "the mentorship program our design team built from scratch."]

The projects and traditions that stick are always the ones people create for each other, not because they have to.

Anyway, I just thought you might like a closer look at what makes our team feel like a team.

Catch you soon,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

2. Silver Medalist Sequence

For great candidates who made it far but didn’t get the offer

Not every “no” is a goodbye.

Silver medalists are often your best future hires. They’ve already shown strong interest and alignment.

Treat them like future teammates, not failed applicants.

Quick Template:

• Start with genuine gratitude for the process.
• Invite them to stay engaged.
• Offer soft updates about future openings or events.
• Keep the door open warmly.

Email 1: Thank You, and Future Connection 

Subject Line: Thank you for the journey

Body:

Hi [First Name],

Wanted to reach out personally and say thank you for spending time with us during the [Role Name] process.

While we went another direction this time, everyone was seriously impressed with what you brought to the table.

Would love to stay connected! We’re always growing, and I’d be thrilled to have you in mind for future roles that might be a better fit.

Talk soon,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Email 2: Check-In and Light Invite

(Send about 4–6 weeks later.) 

Subject Line: Checking in — hope you're well

Body:

Hey [First Name],

Just checking in to say hello and see how everything’s going on your side.

We’ve had some exciting new projects pop up lately. If you’re ever open to chatting again or just curious about what’s next at [Company Name], let’s stay in touch.

Hope everything’s great with you,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

3. Passive Talent Engagement Sequence

For candidates browsing your brand but not actively applying

These are the lurkers - the candidates who are watching but not ready to take action. 

Great talent often gets curious long before they raise their hand.

Quick Template:

• Share problem-solving content or innovation stories.
• Highlight employee spotlights or life inside the team.
• Keep it light, no heavy calls to action.

Email 1: A Cool Problem We’re Solving

Subject Line: What we’re working on behind the scenes

Body:

Hey [First Name],

Thought you might enjoy a little peek into what the [Team Name] team has been up to lately.

One of the coolest challenges they tackled recently: [Insert short real example, e.g., “cutting onboarding time by 30% without sacrificing quality.”]

Fun problems are what keep our teams growing. Always happy to share more if you’re curious.

Catch you around,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Email 2: Employee Spotlight

(Send 2–3 weeks after.) 

Subject Line: Meet [Employee Name]: [Quick Hook]

Body:
Hi [First Name],

Wanted to introduce you to one of our team members, [Employee Name].

[Employee Name] joined us last year and has been [insert quick, real win — e.g., "building out our DEI leadership initiatives" or "leading our most ambitious product rollout yet"]

Stories like [Employee Name]’s are a big part of why people stick around here.

Catch you soon,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

4. Re-Engagement Sequence

For cold candidates, you want to warm back up after 6+ months of no contact

Life changes. Great candidates who said no once might say yes now. 

Don’t let old prospects gather dust.

Quick Template:

• Share a quick update about the company or team.
• Mention any leadership moves, new missions, or product shifts.
• Open the door lightly without assuming interest.

Email 1: Quick Update and Soft Invite 

Subject Line: Been a minute — quick hello

Body:

Hey [First Name],

It’s been a while since we last got in touch. Thought I’d send a quick hello.

[Company Name] has had some exciting changes lately — [Insert update like "new leadership in engineering," "new markets we’re expanding into," or "a major product launch."]

If you’re ever curious to hear more or just catch up, the door’s open.

Hope all’s good on your end,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Email 2: New Opportunities Light Nudge

(2–3 weeks after.) 

Subject Line: Exploring new challenges?

Body:

Hi [First Name],

No big pitch — just wanted to drop a note that we’ve got some new roles opening up soon across [Team/Department Name].

If you’re ever thinking about what’s next, I would love to catch up and hear what you’re looking for.

Zero pressure. Just keeping in touch.

Cheers,
[Recruiter's Name]
[Recruiter's Title]

Best Practices for Writing Your Nurture Sequences

1. Keep It Short and Skimmable

Candidates are busy. They are checking your email between meetings, during commutes, and at the end of long workdays. 

A giant block of text will almost always get skipped.

The best nurture emails feel like quick conversations. Two to three short paragraphs. A clear point. A human sign-off.

If it feels like work to read it, it will never get read.

2. Make Every Email Add Real Value

Every time you send a message, you are either building trust or losing attention.

Sending a "just checking in" email with nothing new to say does not build anything. Share a story. Drop a small update. Give them a piece of insight about your team or work.

Even a small behind-the-scenes note can feel meaningful when it is real.

The goal is to make every touchpoint worth the candidate’s time.

3. Stay Consistent with Tone

Candidates should feel like they are hearing from the same team every time they open an email, not switching between corporate scripts and casual notes.

The best tone feels friendly but clear. You are professional, but you are also a person talking to another person.

You need to sound like someone they might want to work with.

4. Invite Two-Way Conversations

The best nurture programs do not just broadcast. They invite replies.

Host small AMAs. Offer spots at casual webinars. Drop quick surveys that help you learn what matters to candidates.

When you create chances for two-way conversation, you stop treating candidates like leads and start treating them like future teammates.

5. Blend Automation with Personal Touches

Automation is useful. It can keep the lights on when things get busy. 

But real connections happen when a recruiter sends a quick note, not when a sequence drips out another templated message.

Block time once a quarter to review your warm pipelines and send a few personal nudges. 

Even a short "Thought of you when I saw this project open up" makes a huge difference!

Nurturing Is the New Recruiting

Setting up nurture sequences now does not just help you next week or next quarter. It shapes who will pick up your call six months from now, or even next year.

When candidates trust you before a job is open, hiring moves faster. Offers close quicker. The right people walk through the door, already excited.

In a world drowning in AI-driven noise, Puck helps you rise above by surfacing the right people, telling the right stories, and making the whole process feel more human, not less.

The teams that invest in human, consistent, thoughtful nurture are the teams that will own the market when everyone else sounds the same.

Want to see how top teams are building nurture campaigns that candidates want to open?

Book a quick demo with Puck here.

‍